The short answer
The three methods get ink onto a shirt in different ways:
- Screen printing pushes ink through a stencil on a mesh screen, one screen per colour.
- DTG (direct-to-garment) prints ink directly onto the fabric with an inkjet-style printer.
- DTF (direct-to-film) prints the design on a film, adds adhesive powder and heat-presses it onto the shirt.
That difference drives everything else: setup cost, which fabrics work, how detailed the print can be and how it feels.
How each process works
Screen printing. A screen is prepared for each colour. Ink is squeegeed through the open areas of the mesh, then cured with heat. Setup takes time, but printing many copies is quick.
DTG. The design is printed straight onto the shirt, usually with water-based pigment ink. Dark shirts normally need pretreatment and a white underbase. Heat cures the ink afterwards. See DTG printers and pigment ink.
DTF. The design is printed in mirror image on a film using colour and white ink, coated with hot-melt powder, cured, then pressed onto the garment. The film is peeled off after pressing. See what DTF printing is.
Three-way comparison
| Factor | Screen printing | DTG | DTF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup | Screens per colour | None | None (film is printed per design) |
| Best order size | Larger runs | One to small runs | Small to medium runs |
| Colours | Limited by screens | Full colour | Full colour |
| Fine detail and gradients | Possible, but harder | Strong | Strong |
| Fabrics | Wide range | Best on cotton or high-cotton | Cotton, polyester, blends |
| Pretreatment | No | Usually, for dark shirts | No |
| Feel | Ink sits in and on the fabric; can feel slightly raised | Usually soft, ink sinks in | Often a thin layer on top |
| Durability | Generally the most durable on cotton when well cured | Good with care | Good when pressed correctly |
| Special inks | Metallic, puff, glitter and others | Limited | Limited |
Take these as general patterns. Individual printers, inks and garments change the result.
Differences that matter most
Quantity and cost structure
Screen printing has a front-loaded cost. Making screens is time-consuming, so a single shirt is expensive, but the cost per shirt drops as quantity rises. DTG and DTF have little or no setup, so small orders are practical, though each shirt costs roughly the same regardless of quantity. See best t-shirt printing method for small orders.
Fabrics
DTG is happiest on cotton and cotton-rich fabrics. DTF has a wider range and is commonly used on cotton, polyester and blends. Screen printing works across many fabrics, though inks and curing temperatures must suit the material.
Detail and colour
DTG and DTF handle photographs, gradients and many colours without extra cost. Screen printing is best with bold artwork in a limited number of colours, though halftones can reproduce tones.
Feel and durability
DTG usually feels soft because ink soaks into the fibres. DTF forms a thin layer on top, which some people describe as plasticky and others find unnoticeable, depending on the film and technique. Screen printing is generally regarded as the most durable of the three, though a well-made DTF or DTG print can last well with proper care. Curing and washing habits matter as much as the method. Our guide to which method lasts the longest goes deeper.
Which one should you choose?
- Screen printing: many shirts, a few solid colours, long wear, special inks.
- DTG: few shirts, detailed or photographic art, 100% cotton.
- DTF: small to medium runs, mixed fabrics or garments where DTG struggles.
Many shops use more than one. For the wider context, see screen printing vs digital printing and t-shirt printing methods compared.