Short answer
For a single shirt or a small run, a method without screens is usually the best value: DTG for detailed designs on cotton, DTF for flexibility across fabrics, and heat transfer vinyl for names, numbers and simple graphics. Screen printing becomes more attractive as quantities rise, but the point where it wins depends on the design and the shop.
Why small orders are different
Screen printing requires screens, one per colour, plus press setup and registration. That work costs about the same whether you print 5 shirts or 50, so the cost per shirt is high when the quantity is low and falls as quantity grows. DTG, DTF and vinyl avoid screens, so a single shirt is practical. Their cost per shirt stays more constant as quantity increases.
Best methods by order size
| Order size | Often a good fit | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 shirt | DTG, DTF, vinyl, or a home method | No setup needed |
| A handful to a few dozen | DTG, DTF or vinyl, depending on the design | Compare quotes; a shop may offer low minimums |
| Dozens to hundreds | Screen printing, especially for few-colour designs | Setup is spread over more shirts |
One shirt
Pick based on the design. A detailed, full-colour graphic on a cotton shirt suits DTG. A shirt in an unusual fabric, or a multi-colour design that is awkward for DTG, may suit DTF. A name or short phrase suits vinyl. If you want to make it yourself, read how to print on t-shirts at home.
A handful to a few dozen
This middle zone is where quotes matter. A print shop might offer DTG or DTF at a low minimum, or screen printing if your design has only one or two colours. Larger numbers of colours push screen printing costs up faster than digital methods.
When screen printing starts to win
Figures such as “about 20 or more” or “50 or more” shirts per design are often quoted as the tipping point, and some sources suggest bulk screen printing makes sense above a few dozen. In practice the number depends on how many colours you need, the shop’s setup fees and whether you need repeat orders. Ask for quotes at several quantities, for example 12, 24 and 48, and compare the cost per shirt.
Names, numbers and simple text: heat transfer vinyl
Heat transfer vinyl is cut from sheets and pressed on. It suits team names and numbers because every shirt can be different, with no setup cost. It works best for simple shapes. Intricate designs take time to cut and weed, and large vinyl areas can feel stiff.
Print-on-demand vs printing yourself
- Print-on-demand or a print service. You upload a design and they print and ship, with no equipment or stock on your side. Good for one-offs and testing designs. See where to get good quality printed t-shirts.
- Printing yourself. Gives control, but you need a heat press, a cutter or a DTG or DTF printer, which is a bigger investment than a handful of shirts will repay. See DTG printers and pigment ink and what DTF printing is for what the equipment involves.
How to compare quotes
- Ask for a price per shirt at several quantities, not just one.
- Ask about setup fees, screen fees and file fees.
- Ask about minimum order quantities for each method.
- Check what blank shirt is included. See best blank t-shirts for printing.
- Confirm turnaround and how reprints are handled.
For the wider picture, see screen printing vs digital printing and t-shirt printing methods compared.