Printing Methods Compared

T-Shirt Printing Methods Compared: Which Is Best?

Compare screen printing, DTG, DTF, sublimation and heat transfer vinyl by cost, quality, durability and order size to find the best way to print t-shirts.

On this page
  1. Short answer: there is no single best method
  2. The main t-shirt printing methods at a glance
  3. What is the most efficient method?
  4. Which method fits your situation
  5. What kind of printing machine does each method use?
  6. Can you print your own shirts?
  7. Where to go next

Short answer: there is no single best method

The best way to print a t-shirt depends on three things: how many shirts you need, what the design looks like, and what the shirt is made of. Screen printing is usually the most cost-efficient for larger runs of bold, few-colour designs. Direct-to-garment (DTG) and direct-to-film (DTF) suit small runs and detailed, full-colour artwork. Sublimation suits polyester, and heat transfer vinyl suits names, numbers and simple shapes.

Most print shops use more than one method for this reason. The sections below explain each one so you can match the method to your job.

The main t-shirt printing methods at a glance

Method How it works Usually best for Main limits
Screen printing Ink is pushed through a mesh stencil, one screen per colour Larger runs, bold designs, long-lasting prints Setup per colour; less practical for one-offs and photos
DTG An inkjet-style printer applies water-based ink directly to the shirt Small runs, full-colour detail, cotton Works best on cotton; machine upkeep; slower per shirt
DTF A design is printed on film, coated with adhesive powder and heat-pressed on Small to medium runs, mixed fabrics Needs specialist equipment; print can sit on top of the fabric
Sublimation Dye turns to gas under heat and bonds with polyester fibres All-over prints and sportswear on polyester Not suited to cotton or dark shirts
Heat transfer vinyl (HTV) Shapes are cut from vinyl and pressed on Names, numbers, simple logos Fine detail is hard to cut and weed; can feel stiff

Screen printing

Screen printing, sometimes still called silk screen printing, pushes ink through a mesh that has been blocked off in the non-image areas. Each colour in the design needs its own screen, and each is printed in turn and then cured with heat. Once the screens are made, printing more shirts is quick, which is why the method is the standard choice for larger orders.

Its strengths are durability, strong colour on many fabrics and low cost per shirt as quantity rises. Its weaknesses are setup time, cost for small runs and difficulty with photographic detail. For a closer look, see our comparison of screen printing and digital printing.

Direct-to-garment (DTG)

DTG works like a desktop inkjet printer built for fabric. The shirt sits on a platen and water-based pigment ink is printed straight onto it. Dark garments usually need a pretreatment and a white underbase so colours show up. There are no screens, so a single shirt costs about the same effort as a hundred different designs. Our guide to DTG printers and pigment ink covers the process in more detail.

Direct-to-film (DTF)

DTF prints a mirrored design onto a special film, adds a hot-melt adhesive powder, then heat-presses the transfer onto the garment and peels the film away. It is popular because it can work on cotton, polyester and blends without the pretreatment DTG needs. Read what DTF printing is and how it works for the full process and trade-offs.

Sublimation

Sublimation uses special dye that, under heat and pressure, becomes a gas and bonds with polyester fibres. The result is soft to the touch and does not sit on the surface, but it only works well on white or light polyester. It is a good fit for sportswear and all-over prints rather than a standard cotton tee.

Heat transfer vinyl (HTV)

HTV is cut from coloured vinyl sheets with a cutting machine, the excess is removed (weeded), and the design is pressed on with heat. It is good for team names and numbers and simple graphics, and it is a popular home method. Detailed artwork is slow to weed, and large solid areas can feel less breathable.

Embroidery is sometimes listed alongside these methods. It stitches thread into the garment rather than printing, and it is usually the most expensive of the options for a given design.

What is the most efficient method?

“Efficient” can mean cheapest per shirt, fastest to set up or fastest to produce, and the answer changes with each.

  • Lowest setup effort: DTG, DTF and vinyl need no screens, so one shirt can be made quickly.
  • Lowest cost per shirt at volume: screen printing, because setup is spread over many shirts.
  • Fastest production on a big order: screen printing, especially with an automatic press.

The quantity at which screen printing starts to win depends on the number of colours and on the shop. Figures of roughly a dozen to a few dozen shirts are often quoted, but ask for quotes rather than relying on a rule of thumb. We cover this in best t-shirt printing method for small orders.

Which method fits your situation

  • A handful of shirts with a detailed or photographic design: DTG or DTF.
  • Dozens or hundreds of shirts with a simple one to four colour design: screen printing.
  • Team names and numbers: heat transfer vinyl.
  • Performance polyester with an all-over design: sublimation.
  • Mixed fabrics and small runs: DTF is often the practical choice.
  • Maximum durability: screen printing is generally regarded as the most durable option on cotton. See which printing method lasts the longest.

Is DTG good quality? Generally yes, especially for detail and a soft feel on cotton, though results depend on the printer, the pretreatment and the garment. For a three-way look at DTG, DTF and screen printing, read the key differences between DTF, DTG and screen printing.

What kind of printing machine does each method use?

  • Screen printing: a manual or automatic press holds the screens, with an exposure unit to make the stencils and a dryer to cure the ink.
  • DTG: a dedicated garment printer, plus a heat press or dryer to cure.
  • DTF: a roll-to-roll film printer that handles white ink, a powder-applying and curing step, and a heat press.
  • Sublimation: a sublimation printer, transfer paper and a heat press.
  • HTV: a vinyl cutter and a heat press.

A heat press features in four of the five methods, so it is often the most useful single machine to understand.

How a heat press print works, step by step

  1. Turn the press on and set the temperature and time given by the transfer manufacturer. Many transfers fall around the 300 to 340°F range, but instructions differ.
  2. Lay the shirt flat on the lower platen and pre-press for a few seconds to remove wrinkles and moisture.
  3. Position the transfer, usually face down, using a ruler or guide.
  4. Close the press for the recommended time at the pressure the maker specifies.
  5. Peel hot, warm or cold as the instructions say.

Always follow your transfer maker’s settings over any general figure.

Can you print your own shirts?

Yes. Options at home include heat transfer paper, vinyl with a cutting machine, stencils with fabric paint and basic screen printing. They vary widely in durability and look. Our guide on how to print on t-shirts at home walks through each.

Where to go next

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →