Sublimation

Sublimation vs Pigment T-Shirt Printing

Compare sublimation dye printing with pigment-based methods like screen printing, DTG and DTF: fabrics, dark shirts, feel, setup and which to choose.

On this page
  1. The short version
  2. What each method does to the fabric
  3. Side-by-side comparison
  4. Where sublimation wins
  5. Where pigment-based methods win
  6. Disadvantages of sublimation printing
  7. Sublimation vs UV printing
  8. Which should you choose

The short version

Sublimation uses dye that turns to gas and becomes part of polyester fibers. “Pigment” printing uses pigment-based ink, which is made of tiny colored particles that stay on or around the fibers instead of dissolving into them. In t-shirt work, that covers screen printing inks, most DTG (direct-to-garment) inks and DTF (direct-to-film) transfers.

Rule of thumb: sublimation suits light polyester and polymer-coated items, while pigment-based methods suit cotton, blends and dark shirts. There are exceptions, and the details below explain the trade-offs.

The term “pigment printing” is used loosely, and some sources use it for a specific type of inkjet ink or for textile pigment printing in factories. Here it means the pigment-based methods most small shops and hobbyists compare against sublimation.

What each method does to the fabric

Sublimation:

  • Dye is printed on paper, then heat and pressure turn it into gas that enters polyester.
  • The dye is translucent. Shirt color affects the result, and white can’t be printed.
  • The print generally has no raised feel.

Pigment-based methods:

  • Screen printing pushes ink through a stencil screen. The ink forms a layer on the fabric and is cured. Opaque inks cover dark shirts.
  • DTG sprays water-based pigment ink onto the garment, often with a white underbase for dark shirts.
  • DTF prints onto a film, adds adhesive, and presses the film onto the garment.

The pigment sits on or around the fabric surface, so it can sometimes be felt, depending on the method and ink.

Side-by-side comparison

Sublimation Pigment-based (screen, DTG, DTF)
Ink type Dye Pigment
Best fabric White or light polyester Cotton, blends and many others
Dark shirts Poor, no white ink Generally workable with a white layer or opaque ink
Feel Usually no raised feel Varies; often a surface layer
Full-color detail Very good Good, but varies by method
Setup No screens Screens for screen printing; film steps for DTF
Best for Small runs, photo-style and all-over designs Screen printing: larger runs of simpler designs

Durability depends heavily on materials, application and washing, so we don’t promise specific wash counts. Sublimation is generally considered durable on polyester because the dye is inside the fiber, while surface layers can crack or fade over time if poorly applied or cared for.

Where sublimation wins

  • Detail and color range. Photos, gradients and many colors are no harder than a simple design.
  • Soft feel. The print is part of the fabric on suitable polyester.
  • No screens or film. For small orders of different designs, there’s no per-design setup beyond the file.
  • Hard goods. The same printer can decorate polymer-coated mugs, coasters and panels.

Where pigment-based methods win

  • Cotton and dark shirts. Sublimation can’t deliver on these, as covered in our guide to sublimating dark shirts.
  • Larger runs. Screen printing is often more efficient once screens are made and the same design is printed many times.
  • Opaque, bold colors. Opaque inks give strong results on many fabrics.
  • Fabric choice. You aren’t limited to polyester.

Disadvantages of sublimation printing

  • Works only on polyester or polymer-coated surfaces.
  • Light shirts only, and white in your design is the shirt’s color.
  • Setup cost: printer, ink, paper and press, with ongoing consumables.
  • Mistakes can be hard to fix.
  • Print sizes are limited by your printer and paper.
  • Polyester blanks may feel less like cotton unless you choose soft-feel polyester, see the best t-shirt material for sublimation.

Sublimation vs UV printing

UV printing uses ink that is cured instantly with ultraviolet light. It is used mainly on flat, rigid or textured items such as signs, phone cases and promotional products, and the ink sits on the surface. Sublimation uses heat to move dye into polyester or a coating. They are different processes aimed at different products, and UV printing is not a common route for soft shirts.

Which should you choose

  • Light polyester shirts, full-color or all-over designs, small runs: sublimation. Start with our beginner’s tutorial.
  • Cotton or dark shirts: a pigment-based method such as screen printing, DTG or DTF.
  • Many shirts with the same simple design: screen printing is often the practical choice.
  • Selling both: many small shops keep a sublimation setup for light polyester and hard blanks, and use another method for dark garments.

If you go with sublimation, you will also need the right equipment; see choosing a sublimation printer for t-shirts.

The complete guide to sublimation

Sublimation T-Shirt Printing: A Beginner's Tutorial
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →